Before purchasing a new vacuum cleaner, the question of power always comes up. Should you choose a stick vacuum, a canister vacuum, or a robot vacuum? Each size has its advantages, but independent tests show clear differences depending on the use. To help you make the right choice, here’s an analysis of the 5 essential criteria: actual power, carpet performance, maneuverability, battery life, and maintenance. This comparison will help you know which vacuum cleaner to choose.
Broom, sled, or robot vacuum cleaner: which to choose?
Based on the elements below, discover the key points that separate the three types of vacuum cleaners
1. Raw suction power: the sled advantage
When it comes to pure power, the canister vacuum cleaner remains the clear winner. Thanks to a larger motor, it produces higher vacuum and airflow than stick or robot vacuums. In laboratory tests, it excels at vacuuming embedded dirt, especially on thick carpets or rugs. Bagged models even retain their power longer than bagless cyclonic models. However, this performance comes with a larger footprint and often requires a cord to manage.
2. The broom, a good compromise between power and lightness
The cordless stick vacuum cleaner is becoming increasingly popular thanks to its cordless design and ease of use. For example, the most powerful high-end vacuum cleaners today offer sufficient power for hard floors and thin carpets. Some are equipped with digital motors reaching 120 AW to 200 AW, which allows for efficient daily cleaning. However, their battery life in maximum power mode is limited to around ten minutes. The stick vacuum remains ideal for small areas and quick cleanings, but is less suitable for extended sessions.
3. Robots: practical and functional
Robot vacuums are designed for practicality, not power records. Their more compact motor limits their effectiveness on thick carpets or large debris. However, they perform well on hard floors and thin rugs thanks to their regular, programmable suction. Some models even include a mop function or smart sensors to optimize cleaning routes. To effortlessly maintain daily cleanliness, a robot is a good solution.
4. Performance on carpets and rugs: the sled remains unbeatable
If your home has a lot of carpets or rugs, the choice of vacuum cleaner is crucial. Tests show that only cylinder vacuums (with motorized brushes) can effectively remove deep-seated dust. Brooms can handle this, but their lightness sometimes works against them when it comes to properly pressing the head to the floor. As for more advanced robots, they can comfortably clean your floors thanks to their built-in automatic systems. Furthermore, for deep cleaning of floor textiles, a powerful cylinder vacuum is essential.
5. Maintenance, noise, and autonomy: the broom and the robot score points
Beyond power, choosing a vacuum cleaner also depends on daily use. Cordless vacuums recharge quickly and require little maintenance, especially with an easy-to-empty dust bin. Robots, on the other hand, operate autonomously and can even empty themselves into a dedicated station. In terms of noise, sleds are often the noisiest, although some quiet models exist. Finally, the cordless freedom of brooms and the programming of robots offer much greater user comfort.
Conclusion
According to comparative tests, the canister vacuum cleaner is the most powerful of all, especially for difficult floors. The stick vacuum cleaner offers a good balance between performance and lightness, ideal for small spaces or frequent use. As for the robot vacuum cleaner, it offers a connected and autonomous solution for routine maintenance. The choice therefore depends on your needs: maximum power, autonomy, or practicality? By identifying your priorities, you will easily find the vacuum cleaner best suited to your needs.
Spanish 
English